top of page
Publications & News


When Sick Leave Becomes A Legal Risk For Employers
The relationship between medical evidence and employment decisions is becoming an increasingly delicate one. A recent High Court decision illustrates how easily employers can misstep when illness, workplace expectations and legal obligations collide. In Sunshine Bread Sdn Bhd (formerly known as Auric Flavours Sdn Bhd) v Tan Seng Kok [2025] MLJU 4354, the High Court affirmed that an employee dismissed while recovering from severe illness had been terminated without just caus


更替协议的印花税:Mesra Retail 案件解析
Mesra Retail & Cafe Sdn Bhd v Pemungut Duti Setem, Malaysia 一案中,高庭就一份更替协议(Novation Agreement)在《1949年印花税法令》(Stamp Act 1949,简称“SA”)下应如何征收印花税作出裁决。争议焦点在于,该协议应根据附表一第4项征收10令吉的固定印花税,抑或根据附表一第32(a)项征收从价印花税。 案件的关键争议在于,该更替安排是否构成SA第16(1)条意义下的财产转让(conveyance or transfer),或仅是终止原有合同项下的权利与义务,并以新的合同关系取而代之。 本案纳税人由本所税务、消费税与关税合伙人 S. Saravana Kumar 及高级律师 Nur Hanina Mohd Azham 代表出庭并成功抗辩。 事实背景 Petronas Dagangan Berhad(PDB)为多间油站及相关设施的业主。PDB曾与 Golden Scoop Sdn Bhd(Golden Scoop)签订多项营运协议,允许 Golden Sc


The “Duty-Free” Myth: Compliance And Control In Malaysia’s Free Zones
For companies operating in Malaysia’s Free Zones, the perception of a “duty-free” environment often obscures a far more complex regulatory reality. While these zones allow goods to move without immediate customs duties, they exist within a tightly monitored legal framework overseen by the Royal Malaysian Customs Department and the Malaysian Border Control and Protection Agency (MCBA). Enforcement is neither theoretical nor rare. In February 2026, authorities intercepted two


Malaysia–Singapore Renewable Electricity Exports: Legal And Regulatory Considerations For Investors
Malaysia’s decision to permit cross-border exports of renewable electricity is emerging as a significant opportunity for regional energy investors. Following the publication of the third edition of the Guide for Cross-Border Electricity Sales (CBES Guide), developers are increasingly evaluating privately sponsored, project-financed renewable projects designed to supply Singapore’s electricity market. This alert outlines the principal legal and regulatory considerations rele


Acceptance Of Repudiation By Silence Or Non-Performance
When a party repudiates a contract, the innocent party faces an election: to affirm the contract and insist on performance, or to accept the repudiation and treat the contract as discharged. Repudiation alone does not terminate the contract; termination occurs only when the aggrieved party accepts the repudiation. A longstanding question has been whether acceptance must be expressed, or whether it may arise through conduct, particularly through a failure to perform further


上诉庭裁定:债务豁免不构成应税收入
马来西亚上诉庭近日就关联公司贷款豁免的税务处理问题作出一项具有里程碑意义的裁决,明确确立:在纳税人此前未就相关负债申报税务扣除的情况下,债务获豁免并不构成应税收入。 该案 Multi-Purpose Credit Sdn Bhd v Ketua Pengarah Hasil Dalam Negeri [2025] CLJU 2453 不仅厘清了《1967年所得税法令》(Income Tax Act 1967,下称“ITA”)第30(4)条与第4(a)条之间的适用关系,更在原则层面重申了税收法定原则,对企业集团融资安排及资本结构重整具有深远影响。 本案纳税人由本所税务、SST与关税业务部门合伙人 S. Saravana Kumar 先生,联同陈珈桦律师 (Tan Jia Hua) 代表出庭并成功抗辩。 案件核心:债务豁免是否属于“营业所得”? 本案争议源于纳税人作为一家从事信贷租赁、分期付款及一般贷款融资业务的公司,在其日常经营过程中向关联公司借入约7,800万令吉。随后,相关关联公司决定豁免该笔贷款。内陆税收局(IRB)在税务审计过程中认为,纳税


Recalibrating Malaysia’s Listing Framework: Key Proposals Under The Securities Commission Malaysia’s Market Segmentation Review
In November 2025, the Securities Commission Malaysia (SC) issued Public Consultation Paper No. 4/2025 – Market Segmentation Review (the Consultation Paper), proposing targeted refinements to the listing frameworks applicable to the Main Market and ACE Market of Bursa Malaysia. The proposals form part of the SC’s broader initiative to strengthen market segmentation, enhance investor protection and ensure that Malaysia’s capital markets remain competitive and aligned with evolv


Risk, Responsibility And Protection: The Business Judgment Rule In Malaysian Corporate Law
Beneath the glamorous and fast-paced veneer of the corporate world lies a creeping anxiety among directors: that a single lapse in judgment or a wrong commercial decision could lead to their professional crucifixion. This alert seeks to quell such unease by unpacking a foundational doctrine in Malaysian corporate law, namely the business judgment rule and by setting out the confines within which directors may safely exercise their discretion without attracting liability.


上诉法院裁决明确马来西亚短期租赁争议
马来西亚上诉法院就分层建筑短期租赁争议作出重要裁决,并阐明管理公司权限边界及私人契约效力,为长期悬而未决的法律问题提供了明确指引。Wawasan Raya Sdn Bhd v MARC Service Residence Management Corporation [2025] 4 MLRA 1 一案的判决,堪称近年来该领域最具指导意义的司法意见之一。随着爱彼迎(Airbnb)等平台带动短期租赁市场迅速扩张,法律规范却未能同步跟进,致使实务界长期处于规则模糊地带。此项裁决恰逢其时,为业主、更为清晰的法律框架与行动指引。 过去十年,短期租赁已成为都市房产经济的重要组成部分。对业主而言,它意味着可观的租金收益;对住户而言,却往往常伴随安全隐患、人员流动频繁及噪音扰民等现实困扰。为应对这一趋势,许多发展商在项目落成初期,便通过相互契约(Deed of Mutual Covenant)预先设定限制条款,试图在管理机构成立之前, 对单位的使用方式加以规范。。然而,此类私人契约能否凌驾于《马来西亚分层管理法令2013》所构建的法定制度之上,长期以来始终


When Forums Collide: Labour Office vs Industrial Court
The Court of Appeal has drawn a firm jurisdictional line between the Labour Office and the Industrial Court, ruling that once an unfair dismissal claim is before the Industrial Court, the Labour Office is effectively stripped of authority to adjudicate related wage disputes. In Philip Phang Kin Ming & Anor v M Jets International Sdn Bhd (Civil Appeal No: B-04(A)-422-09/2024), the court unanimously held that Section 69A of the Employment Act 1955 (EA) operates as a statutor


Federal Court Clarifies Total Failure Of Consideration And Restitution
The Federal Court delivered a significant clarification of the doctrine of total failure of consideration, restoring analytical discipline to an area of law that had drifted into uncertainty. In Lim Swee Choo & Anor v Ong Koh Hou & Another Appeal [2025] 10 CLJ, the court disentangled restitutionary principle from contractual termination and, in doing so, has reset the architecture of Malaysian unjust enrichment jurisprudence. At issue was a deceptively technical question:


Court Of Appeal Rules Independent Director’s Fees Are Business Income
In a recent decision which was reverberated across boardrooms and tax department alike, the Court of Appeal in OCP v Ketua Pengarah Hasil Dalam Negeri held that the fees received by Independent Non-Executive Directors (INEDs) do not constitute employment income under the Income Tax Act 1967 (ITA). Instead, the court held that such income fell within the scope of business income. The taxpayer in this appeal was successfully represented by the firm’s Tax, SST & Customs partne


Challenging Land Compensation: What Every Landowner Should Know Before The Court Slams The Door
Compulsory land acquisition often sits at the crossroads of constitutional protection and statutory rigidity. While Article 13 of the Federal Constitution guarantees a fair and adequate compensation in the realm of land acquisition, that constitutional promise may collide with the procedural trapdoors embedded within the Land Acquisition Act 1960 (LAA 1960). For a dissatisfied landowner, the path to contesting the Land Administrator's award is not a simple plea for equity b


SAC v Ketua Pengarah Hasil Dalam Negeri: Call Option Fee Falls Within The Scope Of Tax Exemption
The decision of the Special Commissioners of Income Tax (SCIT) in SAC v Ketua Pengarah Hasil Dalam Negeri raises important questions concerning the scope of ministerial tax exemptions under Section 127(3A) of the Income Tax Act 1967 (ITA), the legal character of call options over land and the limits of administrative reinterpretation of incentive conditions. At its core, the dispute concerned whether the Call Option Fee received by the taxpayer in the Year of Assessment (Y


ESG & Supply Chain Management: Key Risks And Considerations For Malaysian Manufacturers
Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) considerations have moved from the margins to the centre of supply chain management, evolving from a voluntary or reputational exercise into a material legal, commercial and transactional risk. Companies are increasingly expected to take responsibility not only for their own operations, but also for the ESG performance of their suppliers, contractors and business partners across the value chain. For Malaysian manufacturers integrat


Form Over Function: Scanned Signatures And Procedural Integrity In Malaysian Courts
A recent decision of the High Court highlights how procedural rules are being applied in an era of electronic filing, and how far courts are prepared to tolerate technical imperfections where no substantive prejudice is shown. In Shine Technology Pte Ltd v Shine DC Technology Sdn Bhd (Companies (Winding-up) Petition No.: JA-28NCC-156-09/2025), the court considered whether affidavits containing scanned signatures and translated jurats were procedurally defective. The ruling


Court of Appeal Upholds Stay Of Proceedings Pending Disposal Of Tax Dispute
Recently, the Court of Appeal upheld the stay of proceedings granted by the High Court in Winning Paramount Sdn Bhd v Ketua Pengarah Hasil Dalam Negeri (2025) MSTC ¶30-815, effectively suspending enforcement of additional assessments amounting to approximately RM86 million. The decision reinforces that notwithstanding the “pay first, dispute later” framework of the Income Tax Act 1967 (ITA), courts can intervene to prevent undue hardship while a judicial review is underway.


The Evergreen Dispute And The Bank’s Contractual Leverage
In structured finance, conditions precedent are not administrative formalities. They are the contractual mechanisms through which lenders manage risk in relation to legal, regulatory and operational aspects before capital is released. Their function is straightforward: no funds flow until specified conditions are met, and met on time. Borrowers who treat these timelines as flexible do so at their own risk. A recent Malaysian Court of Appeal decision underscores this point wit


When Instagram Evidence Meets The Damages Test:Proving Infringement Is Not The Same As Proving Loss
Court victories in intellectual property disputes often carry an implicit assumption of financial reward. The recent High Court decision in Naili Holdings Sdn Bhd v Sabella Holdings Sdn Bhd [2025] 11 MLJ 169 punctures that assumption. While infringement was clearly established, the court’s sharply reduced damages award serves as a cautionary tale for rights holders who conflate online visibility with evidential certainty. The case offers a timely reminder that in civil lit


Finance Act 2025: Broadening The Tax Net & Tightening The Rules
The Finance Act 2025, enacted alongside the Measures for the Collection, Administration and Enforcement of Tax Act 2025, marks a further step in the government’s effort to broaden the tax base, reduce interpretative uncertainty and strengthen enforcement. Many of the measures take effect from 1.1.2026. Taken together, the reforms signal a shift away from ambiguity-driven tax planning towards a framework where compliance discipline, documentation and transaction characterisa
bottom of page
